On October 22, 2026, a unanimous federal jury awarded $51,800,000 to Matilde Garza against San Berardino County and San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department (SBSD) deputies Bill Abernathy and Nicholas Kridner for the fatal shooting of her son, Antonio Garza, Jr. HSRD attorneys Brian Olney, David Washington, and Rebecca Brown represented Matilde Garza at trial. The verdict is the largest in a police shooting case in California history and is believed to be the third largest such verdict ever awarded by a jury in the United States.
On February 5, 2023, the SBSD deputies chased Mr. Garza, who suffered from serious mental illness, through the empty desert near the Whitewater Cutoff in Whitewater, California. The deputies shot Mr. Garza 12 times, including in the back and while he lay on the ground in the fetal position. He was 44 years old.
This case exposes the serious problems in how law enforcement agencies interact with people with disabilities. Persons with serious mental illness are 11 times more likely to be the victim of a police use of force, and 20% of all victims of fatal police shootings between 2015 and 2024 suffered from some form of mental illness. Although proven tactics for safely interacting with such persons are well known to law enforcement agencies including the SBSD, the deputies used none of them here.
Media outlets including the LA Times, NBC, and Telemundo have featured Mr. Olney, Mr. Washington, and Ms. Brown discussing this groundbreaking verdict.
- The Los Angeles Times article entitled San Bernardino County Owes $51 Million to Mother of Mentally Ill Man Killed by Deputies, Jury Says is available at https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2026-10-23/garza-shooting-verdict-federal-trial-award
- The NBC story entitled Family Awarded $51.8M Verdict in Fatal Shooting by San Bernardino Deputies, Attorneys Say is available at https://www.nbclosangeles.com/news/local/family-awarded-verdict-fatal-san-bernardino-deputy-shooting/3959794/
- The ABC story entitled Family of Man Killed by Deputies in IE Awarded Nearly $52M, Urges AG to File Criminal Charges is available at https://abc7.com/post/family-man-killed-san-bernardino-county-deputies-awarded-nearly-52-million-dollars-seeks-criminal-charges/19973388/
- The CBS story entitled Jury Awards $51 Million to Family of Inland Empire Man Shot and Killed by Deputies in 2023 is available at https://www.cbsnews.com/losangeles/news/51-million-inland-empire-antonio-garza-killed-deputies-2023/
- The Telemundo story entitled Familia Obtiene Histórico Veredicto de $51.8 Millones por Muerte de Hombre a Manos del Sheriff is available at https://www.telemundo52.com/noticias/local/familia-obtiene-historico-veredicto-de-51-8-millones-por-muerte-de-hombre-a-manos-del-sheriff/2909167/
- The Daily Journal article entitled Jury Awards $51.8m in Fatal San Bernardino Deputy Shooting is available at https://www.dailyjournal.com/article/395570
- The San Bernardino Sun article entitled $51.8 Million Awarded to Mother of Man Killed by San Bernardino County Deputies is available at https://www.sbsun.com/2026/10/23/51-8-million-awarded-to-family-of-man-killed-by-san-bernardino-county-deputies/
- The Hi-Desert Star article entitled Family of Man Killed by Deputies Awarded $51 Million; Garza was Shot in Back, while in Fetal Position, Attorney Says is available at https://www.hidesertstar.com/deserttrail/family-of-man-killed-by-deputies-awarded-51-million-garza-was-shot-in-back-while/article_22063138-d679-4293-bfaa-b6fa844dd45d.html